The Kindle Dilemma

This Christmas, my dear wife purchased me an e-reader. It started out as a Barnes and Noble Nook, but after some research (especially into how many academic-type books there are on each) I decided a Kindle was more useful to me. So I ordered one.

And waited.

And waited.

Its delivery was delayed, one got lost in the mail, and mine finally arrived on the day after Apple made its big iPad announcement.

Thus the dilemma: do I keep the Kindle, or send it back in anticipation of getting a cool new Apple product?

I decided to keep the Kindle. The reasons had mostly to do with the fact that I don’t need another computer-like device: I have a MacBook, I’ll probably have an iPhone in a couple months, I have a smart phone now. I don’t need another e-mail machine, etc.

There was also the concern that with as much as it does, the iPad won’t do as well the one thing that the Kindle does: allow me to read books.

The Kindle has an easy-to-read screen and an extraordinarily long battery life (40ish hours). The max “10 hours” of the iPad didn’t sound all that attractive in comparison, and the screen would be much harder on the eyes.

So I opened my Kindle, but still not entirely sure what I’d do with it. Do I purchase professional books in a format that might become obsolete? Do I buy fiction books that I might read once or twice–but could have checked out of the library?

Then I found my way.

My Kindle exists primarily to provide me with countless hours of reading in classic literature that I can download for free from the internet. So, in honor of this lovely device and its newfound home in my heart, I offer you the first sentences of some of the books I uploaded in my first Kindle “book run”:

“The artist is the creator of beautiful things.”

“Κατ͗ αρχάς παρουσιάζονται προ των βωμών που ήσαν εμπρός από το ανάκτορον του Οιδίποδος γέροντες και νέοι Θηβαίοι στεφανωμένοι με ικετηρίους κλάδους.” (diacritical marks kept as they are in the eb00k)

“The Nellie, a cruising yawl, swung to her anchor without a flutter of the sails, and was at rest.”

“A cloud was on the mind of men, and wailing went the weather,Yeah, a sick cloud upon the soul when we were boys together.”

“A wolf, finding that the sheep were so afraid of him that he could not get near them, disguised himself in the dress of a shepherd, and thus attired approached the flock.”

“Emma Woodhouse, handsome, clever, and rich, with  a comfortable home and happy disposition, seemed to unite some of the best blessings of existence; and had lived nearly twenty-one years in the world with very little to distress or vex her.”

“My father’s family name being Pirrip, and my Christian name Philip, my infant tongue could make of both names nothing longer or more explicit than Pip.”

“At night, in winter, when the snow-flakes fall slowly from heaven like great white tears, I raise my voice; its resonance thrills the cypress trees and makes them bud anew.”

“In the war of Troy, the Greeks having sacked  some of the neighbouring towns, and taken from thence two beautiful captives, Chryseis and Briseis, allotted the first to Agamemnon and the last to Achilles.”

“Those who undertake to write histories, do not, I perceive, take that trouble on one and the same account, but ofr many reasons, and those such as are very different one from another.”

“Call me Ishmael.”

“Midway upon the journey of our life I found myself within a forest dark, For the straightforward pathway had been lost.”

That’s the first line of about 1/5 of the free books I uploaded to my reader in about 45 seconds. I’m not trying to sell these things, but mine now has a purpose. And I have a mission: read everything.

This entry was written by J. R. Daniel Kirk , posted on Saturday January 30 2010at 05:01 pm , filed under Kindle Reading . Bookmark the permalink . Post a comment below or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

10 Responses to “The Kindle Dilemma”

  • Ed Gentry says:

    I did the same thing with my Palm Pilot almost 10 years ago. The screen wasn’t as good of course but the idea was the same. A platform for reading public domain books.

    I for one am not going to by an e-reader until there is a public cross-vender standard for e-books. I even have *some* mixed feelings about Libronix in this respect. On the other hand who wants to actually have an ABD on your book shelf when you can search it on your computer.

  • S. Daniel Owens says:

    I think the Kindle needs to go back, that is if, the kindle app will work on the Ipad. Also, Ipad uses the standard e-pub def a plus.

  • I’ve also been thinking that I would prefer Kindle over iPad for reading. I expect that lots of publishers will increasingly add multi-media components to their ebooks, giving iPad the edge in those cases, but there’s so much more that would be easier to read (both on the eyes and the battery) using a device like the Kindle.

    I’m really curious to find out how Hebrew text looks and wraps on Kindle, assuming it can display Hebrew unicode. I would love to have the first electronic version in the Harvard Theological Studies series (they appear to be willing), but I have quite a bit of Hebrew mixed in with the English text. Even if the font doesn’t present a problem, I’m worried that it can’t properly adjust the word wrap when increasing or decreasing the text size. Have you run across any Hebrew or other right-to-left scripts mixed with left-to-right text so far?

  • Daniel, I’m VERY interested in the possibility of getting a Kindle, and so I’d really love to hear more. Two things in particular I’d like to know more about. First, there are pdf files on Archive.org with all sorts of interesting things for folks like us – Apostolic Fathers in Greek, Mandaic texts, Aramaic and Syriac grammars and chrestomathies. I’ve sometimes found such texts will not display on my Pocket PC. Any chance you can try them on the Kindle? I’d love to know how such things look.

    The other question I have is whether note taking is a great inconvenience. Typing on an iPod or Pocket PC is never as fast as on a regular keyboard, but if it is really awkward, that would still be worth knowing about the Kindle, since if you can read a book and work on writing a review of it or type lecture notes, that would once again make it all the more useful for academics.

    If you have time, I’d love to hear your comments or thoughts about this, whether here or on one of my recent posts about devices like these! :-)

  • Randall and James: I haven’t had an opportunity to use Hebrew or much Greek yet. I’m working on the latter. In particular, I’m not sure if you can put notes on PDFs. I know you can on the “normal” formatting.

    Randall, I anticipate that the Hebrew wrap would be a total pain in the butt unless it’s PDF rather than Amazon’s special format. I mean, even full wordprocessors can’t get that right, so I have little hope for this!

  • I too don’t think the iPad will kill the Kindle. My iPod touch has some books but it is not practical for long sustained reading as the Kindle’s e-ink screen. I don’t have a Kindle yet, but may get one soon enough.

    ireaderreview.com is a good resource for downloading free books and over-all Kindle tricks.

  • I would be curious to read about your thought process behind selecting the Kindle over the Nook. Most folks I read who write about e-readers seem to default to the Kindle as if it’s the only thing out there (although I usually use the Sony Reader as my example of “there are other readers, you know”). You seem to have made a very conscious decision for the Kindle, and I’d be curious as to your thoughts on the strengths and weaknesses of each device.

    • Mark, I chose Kindle over Nook. Nook had a few features that I really liked, such as the ability to loan books out for a couple weeks and read whatever you want in a B&N. But, there were two major reasons I went with Kindle. One was that the Nook was getting some negative reviews based on performance, response times, etc. It seemed they needed to work out some software bugs. The other issue was that there are more New Testament academic books available on Kindle than on Nook. I’m not sure how much I’m going to purchase such books, but if, for example, I anticipate using the same textbook in my intro courses for the next five years, it might be worth it to me to have it on the Kindle so that I can take my books to class without carrying a stack of books 18 inches high. I didn’t look at the Sony.

  • I’m glad for a discussion like this. Daniel, I suspect that you’re right about the Hebrew. I’ve been thinking that the best route is probably to cut out as much of the Hebrew text as I can, and then transliterate what’s left. In that case, I need to find out if Kindle can handle all of the diacritics of academic transliteration. Or maybe I should just go with the standard transliteration to begin with.

    On a different subject, have you considered enabling an option, if available, for commenters to receive notifications when new comments are posted? I know that RSS could handle that, but it would require separate feeds for each page of comments. A notification service, on the other hand, would presumably let me know about new comments months later. Just a thought for the suggestion box.

  • Jonathan B. Horen says:

    It’s half-a-year later, and I’m wondering if anyone has gotten any first-hand experience with Hebrew on the Kindle? I’m curious about native Kindle format, as well as PDF and converted ePUB (by way of “calibre”). Anyone willing to share?

    My interests lie in Torah, commentaries, Talmud, and halacha (in Hebrew, of course).

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>