Several people have asked me to tell a bit of my story. I thought it not a bad idea, so I’ll begin today and probably pick it up a couple days from now.
Once upon a time I was in the Presbyterian Church in America. See? I really was:
No. Wait. I can’t start there. Let’s back up a bit.
Let’s start with 99.44%.
I know, you think this is going to be an Ivory Soap commercial. But Ivory Soap does not have exclusive claim to 99.44% Well, o.k., maybe it does.
So let’s start with 99.4%
Or, 6 out of 1,000.
Or, the number of women who become pregnant in the first year of using an Intrauterine Device (IUD). Like my mom.
Basically what I’m saying is this: I had to stick it to The Man (woman?) who was tryin’ to keep a brother down to even get into this world.
Here, you might start to imagine that the story as it began above, with jrdk in the PCA, will not end well.
At any rate, we must move on past my primordial fight for survival into the throes of kindergarten. And crayons.
Yes, crayons.
Imagine the scene: a group of kindergarteners walks into art class, where we fill in the tables vacated by the previous hour’s second graders.
There, splayed out in all their glory, are good ol’ Crayolas.But the teacher says, “The crayons on the tables were from the big kids’ class. You guys will want to use the bigger crayons because they’re better for your little hands.”
To this, of course, my 5-year-old mind retorted, silently, “That’s dumb. If we have smaller hands, we should be using smallercrayons.”
Although such a posture would wear off in time (obviously!), my five year old self was apparently quite sure of itself when it came to matters academic. More importantly, it was once again clear that if I was going to thrive in this world, I would have to get past The Man (or woman?) who was, once again, trying to keep a brother down.
From an early age the need to fight for what is right was part of my daily experience.
At this point you might be thinking back to the direction the story is heading, with jrdk in the PCA, and thinking that the scene ends badly, as you might imagine, in a cavalcade of anger and fear. Oops, I slipped into Mountain Goats lyrics. Sorry about that.
Where was I? Oh yes, my story…
Skipping ahead a bit, the theologically non-committal moderate Southern Baptist theology I grew up with took a back seat when I was in college. I took a course from Ralph Wood my first semester at Wake Forest University. We read Shirley Guthrie (a.k.a. “baby Barth,” C. S. Lewis, and J. R. R. Tolkien. And we fought about theology.
After a full 15 weeks of asking a different sort of question of the Bible, the traditional theological questions of predestination and the like, I was rapidly becoming a Calvinist without having ever read Calvin.
Of course, I debated matters for a while–at least a couple semesters. But come on, Paul says “predestined,” so let’s not have any of this foolishness about “predestined really means foreknowledge.” Besides, what does Jesus’ lament over Jerusalem, that he wanted to gather her but she was unwilling–what does that have to do with anything? Take your Americana Freedom notions and get them out of my Bible!
As you can see, at the ripe old age of 17, I was well on my way to becoming a Presbyterian.






So the question: Is it possible to recognize this component of the biblical narrative, even to confess its interpretation of the destruction of Jerusalem in AD 70, and withstand the dangerous theological ramifications that have plagued Christian history?



